TL;DR

Silver surged as much as 6% and gold extended a three-session winning streak to multi-week highs on Thursday (May 7), as diplomatic signals pointed toward a possible US-Iran deal to reopen the Strait of Hormuz. Both metals backed off intraday peaks late in the session after US and Iranian forces exchanged fire near the strait -- the most serious ceasefire test since the April 7 truce. Both sides say the situation has since returned to normal, and Pakistan says an interim agreement could come as soon as this weekend.

What Happened: Silver Surge and Gold Rally on Iran Peace Deal Signals

Precious metals markets staged one of their sharpest single-day moves of 2026 on Thursday, driven by mounting evidence that the 69-day US-Iran war may be approaching a negotiated pause.

Silver (XAG/USD) jumped more than 6% intraday to a peak of $82.24 per ounce -- its highest level since mid-April -- before settling around $81.48 to $82.07, still up roughly 5 to 6% on the session, according to Forbes and TheStreet data. Gold (XAU/USD) rose 1.2% to approximately $4,750 per ounce, a multi-week high, extending a three-session winning streak that has lifted prices steadily from recent lows, per Reuters and CNBC.

The rally was sparked by a combination of factors that hit simultaneously Thursday morning. Brent crude had plunged nearly 8% on Wednesday on reports that Iran was reviewing a US one-page memorandum of understanding (MOU) designed to lead to a gradual reopening of the Strait of Hormuz. That oil drop eased inflation expectations, pushed bond yields lower, softened the US dollar, and gave non-yielding assets like gold and silver an immediate lift.

Pakistan, which has been mediating between Washington and Tehran since the April 7 ceasefire, told reporters Thursday that an "interim" agreement could be reached as soon as this weekend. Iran confirmed it is reviewing the US proposal. Key sticking points -- including Iran's nuclear program, its missile capabilities, and limits on its support for armed groups -- remain unresolved, but both sides appear closer to a temporary pause than at any point in recent weeks.

Why Markets Moved: Multiple Tailwinds Hit Precious Metals at Once

Gold and silver have broadly tracked inversely with oil throughout the Iran war. When oil falls sharply on peace-deal optimism, metals benefit from several simultaneous forces:

  • Easing inflation fears: Lower energy prices reduce the inflation premium embedded in bond yields. Falling real yields make non-yielding assets like gold more attractive relative to Treasuries.
  • Softer dollar: The US dollar slipped about 0.15% on Thursday, providing a secondary tailwind for commodities priced in dollars. Sucden Financial analysts cited "renewed diplomatic expectations" and a softer dollar as the main drivers.
  • Industrial demand recovery signal: Silver is used heavily in solar panels, electronics, and medical devices -- not just as a safe-haven metal. If Hormuz reopens and global supply chains normalize, industrial silver demand recovers alongside its safe-haven bid.
  • Gold-silver ratio dynamics: The gold-silver ratio -- how many ounces of silver it takes to buy one ounce of gold -- widened sharply earlier in the conflict as risk aversion spiked. As risk appetite returns, silver tends to outperform gold on the upside, which is exactly what Thursday's price action showed.

TD Securities strategists said in a note cited by Bloomberg that metals were being pushed higher by "headlines of a potential peace deal," but cautioned that these price swings are "extremely fragile to reversal as US and Iranian demands seemingly remain unchanged compared to prior proposals." Soojin Kim of Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group said "falling oil prices and easing inflation concerns pushed bond yields and the dollar lower, supporting gold prices."

Late-Session Ceasefire Test: What Happened at Hormuz

Late Thursday evening, US and Iranian forces exchanged fire near the Strait of Hormuz. Reuters described it as "the most serious test yet" of the April 7 truce.

Iran's military said the US targeted an Iranian oil tanker and another vessel entering the strait, and struck civilian areas on Qeshm Island and along the coastal areas of Bandar Khamir and Sirik. The US Central Command (CENTCOM) said Iranian forces had fired missiles, drones, and small boats at three US Navy destroyers -- USS Truxtun, USS Rafael Peralta, and USS Mason -- transiting the international waterway. CENTCOM said it responded by eliminating threats and striking missile launch sites, drone facilities, and command-and-control locations. No US assets were hit.

Trump told ABC News the ceasefire was still in effect and described the exchange as "just a love tap." Iran's Press TV subsequently reported the situation on Iranian islands and coastal cities was "back to normal."

This exchange follows a similar incident Monday, when the US said it destroyed six Iranian small boats and intercepted Iranian cruise missiles and drones near the strait. The ceasefire has remained technically in place through each of these incidents, but the pattern of recurring skirmishes keeps risk premiums elevated.

Implications for Precious Metals, Futures, and Crypto Traders

Silver traders (XAG/USD): Thursday's 6% move is meaningful. Silver is more volatile than gold precisely because of its industrial demand component. If peace talks succeed and both safe-haven relief and industrial demand recovery align, silver can significantly outperform gold. The near-term risk: any ceasefire collapse would likely hit silver harder than gold, as industrial demand concerns would resurface alongside the risk-off shift.

Gold traders (XAU/USD): Gold's three-session rally has brought it toward $4,750, still well below the March 2026 highs above $5,300 hit at the conflict's peak. A peace deal and Hormuz reopening would likely keep inflation expectations contained and support gold's rate-cut tailwind. Continued ceasefire breakdowns reinforce gold's safe-haven demand. Either way, gold has near-term fundamental support from multiple directions.

Energy and futures traders: Brent crude opened Thursday at $102 and traded around $98-102 after Wednesday's 8% drop. Analyst Vandana Hari (Vanda Insights) put it bluntly: "Crude's slump is once again wildly and prematurely optimistic. The only thing that matters for the market is how and when does the Strait of Hormuz reopen." At present, the chokepoint faces a double blockade -- Iran obstructing traffic and the US Navy blocking vessels calling at Iranian ports.

Crypto traders: Bitcoin has climbed toward $79,000-81,000 recently. Historically, strong gold and silver sessions can provide a macro tailwind for Bitcoin as a non-sovereign store of value, though the correlation varies. For more on what the oil and futures signals mean for risk assets in this environment, see our earlier flash post on the Iran destroyer attack and oil market reaction.

Potential Positives vs Negatives

Potential positives:

  • If a peace deal is signed this weekend as Pakistan suggests, Brent could fall toward $80-85, inflation resets lower, and central banks may lean toward rate cuts -- a powerful combined tailwind for gold and silver.
  • Silver benefits from a dual catalyst: peace-led inflation relief and resumed industrial demand from a recovering global supply chain.
  • Equity indices, which already hit record closing highs Wednesday, could extend gains if risk appetite normalizes.
  • The Trump-Xi summit (May 14-15, Beijing) gives both leaders direct incentive to resolve Hormuz before that meeting, adding a near-term political deadline to the peace process.

Potential negatives:

  • TD Securities' caution is well-founded. This deal has been described as "close" for several weeks. If negotiations break down again, oil spikes back toward $110+, inflation fears re-accelerate, and silver quickly gives back most of its 6% gain.
  • The Thursday exchange of fire -- even with both sides de-escalating -- shows the ceasefire is structurally fragile. The strait itself remains nearly empty of commercial shipping, which is the only meaningful metric for oil market normalization.
  • Any confirmed ceasefire collapse would trigger a sharp risk-off move: oil surges, gold may spike briefly then face profit-taking, and silver could sell off hard as industrial demand concerns return.

What Could Happen From Here: Base, Upside, and Downside Scenarios

Base case (55%): Interim deal signed within days, slow Hormuz reopening begins. Brent eases toward $90-95, gold holds $4,600-4,750, silver consolidates after its spike, and equities extend gains with reduced war premium. Confirm: official statement from Iran's foreign ministry or Pakistani officials on MOU progress within 72 hours.

Upside case (25%): Deal accelerates, shipping resumes faster than expected. Brent drops below $90, inflation fears collapse, Fed signals a rate-cut path opens, and gold breaks above $4,800-4,850 while silver extends toward $85-88 as industrial demand recovers. Confirm: Hormuz shipping data showing vessels beginning transit; supply-chain normalization signals from IMF or WTO.

Downside case (20%): Ceasefire collapses, new escalation beyond "love tap" level. Brent spikes above $110-115, inflation expectations surge, yields rise. Precious metals see short-term profit-taking before a potential second leg higher as the war premium returns. Silver could give back 4 to 5 percentage points quickly. Confirm: large-scale US airstrike on Iranian territory, or Iranian missile or drone attack that damages a US asset; Brent closing above $110 with no diplomatic response within 24 hours.

What to Watch Next (Next 24 Hours)

  • Iran's formal response to the US one-page MOU through Pakistani intermediaries
  • Any follow-on exchange of fire near the Strait of Hormuz
  • Brent crude at Asia open: above $100 signals ceasefire doubt; below $98 signals peace-deal optimism holding
  • Silver spot (XAG/USD): the $83 level is key -- breaking above would mark silver's best session since mid-March 2026
  • Trump social media posts on Iran and the peace process
  • Trump-Xi summit preparations (May 14-15, Beijing) -- China has publicly called for swift Hormuz reopening

FAQ

Q: Why did silver outperform gold so strongly on Thursday?
Silver has both industrial demand (solar, electronics, medical) and safe-haven demand. When inflation fears ease and industrial optimism returns simultaneously, silver captures both tailwinds at once. Gold is primarily a safe-haven and tends to move less dramatically in either direction.

Q: What happens to gold if a US-Iran peace deal is reached?
Gold may hold or even continue rising in the near term. A deal pushes oil lower, which reduces inflation, lowers bond yields, and weakens the dollar -- all tailwinds for gold. The safe-haven war premium would fade, but the rate-cut premium would likely replace it.

Sources

Markets like Thursday's -- fast moves, conflicting signals, fragile narratives -- are where the right habits separate traders who adapt from those who get shaken out. At ChartDojo, you get AI-powered feedback on every trade, so you can see whether your entries, exits, and position sizing reflect your actual edge or just good luck. Build real skills, not bad habits. Start your free trial today.

Header image source: wikimedia by Acabashi. License: CC BY-SA 4.0.