TL;DR

Crude oil fell 7-8% on Wednesday as Axios reported the US and Iran are nearing a 14-point memorandum of understanding to end their two-month-old war. President Trump posted a stark ultimatum: accept the deal or face bombing at a "much higher level." Asia markets surged on the optimism, with Japan's Nikkei 225 crossing 61,000 for the first time ever. The deal remains unsigned, and conflicting signals from Tehran mean traders should stay alert for a reversal.

What Happened: Trump's Ultimatum and the Iran Deal Oil Price Drop

Oil markets had one of their most dramatic single-session moves in years on Wednesday, May 6. Brent crude (the international benchmark) fell nearly 8% to close at $101.27 per barrel, while US West Texas Intermediate (WTI) dropped around 7% to $95.08. The catalyst was a report from Axios citing four sources who said the US and Iran are nearing a one-page, 14-point memorandum of understanding to end the war that began on February 28.

Shortly after, President Trump posted on Truth Social making the framework explicit. He wrote that Operation Epic Fury, the US military campaign against Iran, "will be at an end" if Iran agrees to the terms. If accepted, the US naval blockade of Iranian ports would "allow the Hormuz Strait to be OPEN TO ALL, including Iran." He added that if Iran refused, bombing would resume "at a much higher level and intensity than it was before."

Bloomberg reported early Thursday UTC that Trump separately told aides the US had effectively "won" the campaign. The White House expects Iran to respond to several key points within 48 hours, according to Axios.

Iran's Foreign Ministry confirmed it was "evaluating" the US peace proposal but said Tehran would only accept a deal that was "fair." The New York Times reported Thursday that the two sides were still offering conflicting public messages, signaling the deal is not yet closed.

Why Markets Moved

The Strait of Hormuz handles roughly 20% of global seaborne oil and liquefied natural gas. Since Iran effectively closed the strait in early March, approximately 13 million barrels per day (mb/d) of supply has been disrupted in what analysts are calling the largest energy supply shock in history. That figure has been offset by inventory drawdowns, but stockpiles are declining rapidly, making markets increasingly sensitive to any sign of resolution.

Warren Patterson, head of commodities strategy at ING, said it plainly: "A deal that normalises oil flows through the Strait of Hormuz is crucial." He warned that tighter stocks leave the market "trading in an ever more volatile manner" with each passing day.

The 7-8% single-day oil decline reflects how much of a war premium had been baked into prices. Brent had been trading above $110 at its peak during the conflict. At $101, significant war premium remains, meaning there is still material downside if a deal closes and Hormuz reopens.

Even with a deal signed, analysts caution that shipping and trade flow normalization would take "weeks and weeks" as vessels reposition, insurance terms reset, and port operations resume.

Asia Markets: Nikkei 225 Crosses 61,000 for the First Time

Overnight Thursday, Asian markets opened sharply higher. Japan's Nikkei 225 rose 3.72%, breaking above 61,000 for the first time in its history. Japan had been on holiday for much of the prior week and was catching up to Wednesday's US equity gains alongside fresh optimism from the peace talks. The broader Topix index added 1.91%.

Elsewhere in Asia, Australia's S&P/ASX 200 rose over 1%, and South Korea's Kospi added 1.17%. Hong Kong's Hang Seng futures pointed to a firmer open as well.

The rally came despite Trump's fresh threats of escalated bombing if Iran rejected the deal. Markets appear to be pricing a higher probability of a deal than a breakdown, though that interpretation carries real risk if negotiations stall.

Gold and Broader Cross-Asset Reaction

Gold held substantial gains through the session. Bloomberg noted that truce hopes were easing inflation fears, which had been partly driven by elevated energy costs feeding into global supply chains. Gold typically benefits from geopolitical risk, but it can also benefit from a peace settlement if the resolution is seen as removing a major inflationary tailwind, making monetary policy easier to navigate.

WTI futures ticked back up about 0.92% to $95.95 in overnight Asian trading as of early Thursday UTC, suggesting some traders are fading the single-day decline slightly while the deal outcome remains uncertain.

Implications for Traders

Energy futures traders: The 7-8% drop was sharp but possibly not the full move. If the 14-point MOU is signed and Hormuz reopens, analysts expect oil to normalize significantly lower over weeks as supply returns. Short-term price action will be highly reactive to any headline about Iran's response. A rejection could see WTI and Brent spike back toward or above prior highs quickly.

Equity futures traders: US index futures have already priced considerable peace optimism (S&P 500 and Nasdaq hit records Wednesday). Asian markets are now playing catch-up. If the deal closes, risk assets globally likely have further upside. If negotiations break down, expect a sharp reversal, particularly in airline, shipping, and consumer discretionary names that benefited from the peace trade.

Global equity traders (Japan focus): The Nikkei at 61,000 is a psychologically important milestone. Japan is a major net energy importer, so lower oil prices are a structural positive for Japanese corporate margins. If the Iran deal closes and oil normalizes, Japan's equity rally has credible fundamental backing beyond just momentum.

Macro and fixed income traders: Easing energy prices, if sustained, reduce global headline inflation expectations. This gives central banks, including the Fed, more flexibility. Watch for any shift in rate expectations following sustained oil weakness.

Potential Positives vs Negatives

Positives if the deal closes:

  • Global oil supply shock ends; Brent potentially falls toward $80-90 range over weeks as Hormuz reopens.
  • Shipping normalization reduces freight costs and supply chain disruption globally.
  • 23,000 stranded seafarers from 87 countries can return to normal operations.
  • Inflationary pressure from energy eases, supporting consumer purchasing power and central bank dovishness.
  • Risk assets globally have room to extend the rally already underway.

Negatives and risks:

  • Deal is not signed. Iran is only "evaluating" the proposal and could walk away.
  • Trump's threats add pressure but also raise the risk of a diplomatic breakdown that triggers resumed military action.
  • Even if signed, normalization takes weeks. Shipping insurance and port logistics do not reset overnight.
  • Oil price shorts could be aggressive ahead of any official confirmation, adding volatility in both directions.
  • Regional geopolitical complexity remains. French President Macron's call for a partial Hormuz opening before any truce adds a separate diplomatic layer that may complicate final terms.

What Could Happen From Here: Scenarios for the Next 24-72 Hours

Base case (deal closes within 48 hours): Iran responds positively to at least the key points of the 14-point MOU. Both sides announce a framework agreement. Oil falls another 5-12% as supply return expectations solidify. Asian and European equities extend gains. Nikkei consolidates above 61,000. Confirmed by: an official joint statement or coordinated press releases from Washington and Tehran.

Upside case (rapid Hormuz reopening): A quick agreement allows the US to lift the naval blockade and Iran to reopen shipping lanes within days. Brent crude drops toward $85-90/bbl over the following two to three weeks as 13 mb/d begins returning to market. Global inflation expectations shift materially lower, sparking a broad risk rally and increasing speculation of rate cuts. Confirmed by: an official Hormuz shipping resumption announcement and visible oil flow data from tanker tracking firms.

Downside case (talks collapse): Iran rejects key terms, Trump resumes Operation Epic Fury at elevated intensity. Oil spikes back above $110-115. Risk assets reverse sharply. Airline and logistics stocks, which have been among the biggest peace-trade beneficiaries, would be hit hardest. Confirmed by: Iran officially rejecting the US proposal or Trump announcing resumed strikes.

What to Watch Next (Next 24 Hours)

  • Iran's official response to the 14-point MOU framework, expected within 48 hours per Axios.
  • WTI and Brent price action during European and US trading hours Thursday as traders reassess the probability of a deal.
  • Trump social media posts remain a primary real-time signal on the state of negotiations.
  • Tanker tracking data from firms like Kpler or Vortexa for any early sign of Hormuz traffic movement.
  • US equity futures at the New York open and whether the peace trade extends or fades on mixed signals.
  • Gold price direction as a read on whether inflation fears are truly easing or just temporarily paused.

Sources

Trading around major geopolitical catalysts is one of the hardest skills to develop. Build real skills, not bad habits. ChartDojo uses AI-powered feedback to help you understand why a trade worked or failed, not just whether it did. Start your free trial and sharpen your process before the next big move. For more on recent market catalysts, see: S&P 500 and Nasdaq Hit Records as US-Iran Peace MOU Advances.

Header image source: wikimedia by Michael Garlick. License: CC BY-SA 2.0.